
Compare3AM vs Rootly
Their hypothesis.Our proof.
Rootly's own docs call its output “a hypothesis with evidence, not a verdict.” 3AM confirms the cause live and never writes without two people.
Where Rootly is strong.
Quick to adopt
Fast to set up, popular with fast-moving teams, with published prices for incident response.
rootly.comCandid
Its own docs say plainly that its answer is a hypothesis, not a verdict.
docs.rootly.com
Where a bank decides.
Eight questions a bank's security, risk and operations leads ask before anything touches production.
| Question | Rootly, Rootly AI SRE0 of 8, 2 in part | 3AM8 of 8 |
|---|---|---|
| Runs entirely inside your networkEvery part, management included, on infrastructure you own | Hosted on AWS; inference runs in the US. Private Agent is in early preview. | Every part runs in your network. The only call to us is a signed license check; air-gapped, it verifies offline. |
| Runs air-gappedNo connection out at all | Not found in public docs. | An air-gap bundle ships the images and models together. The license verifies offline. |
| Never copies your telemetryNo ingest, no index, no cached results outside your systems | Read-only queries; some sources are ingested. Prompts are logged for evaluation. | Each question runs where the data lives and a small answer comes back. Nothing is copied out. |
| Proves the cause before actingA live check that confirms it, not a confidence score | “A hypothesis with evidence, not a verdict,” rated high, medium or low. | A live check confirms the cause. Only a confirmed cause can authorize a fix. |
| Applies the fix and verifies itRehearsed first, then checked after it runs | Private Agent can run writes such as SQL without interactive approval. | Every fix is dry-run first, applied with approval, then checked against the live system. |
| Two people approve every writeNot one person, and never switched off by an admin | Not found in public docs. | Two different people approve one plan, and the plan cannot change after they sign. |
| Holds no key to the booksA hard line around ledgers, journals and balances | Not found in public docs. | No key to the books at any setting. A person runs a signed package with their own key. |
| Tamper-evident audit trailHash-chained and signed, verifiable by your auditors | Not found in public docs. | Every step is hash-chained and signed, and exports to your SIEM. |
Inside your network
Every part, management included, on infrastructure you own
Rootly. Hosted on AWS; inference runs in the US. Private Agent is in early preview.
3AM. Every part runs in your network. The only call to us is a signed license check; air-gapped, it verifies offline.
Air-gapped
No connection out at all
Rootly. Not found in public docs.
3AM. An air-gap bundle ships the images and models together. The license verifies offline.
No telemetry copied
No ingest, no index, no cached results outside your systems
Rootly. Read-only queries; some sources are ingested. Prompts are logged for evaluation.
3AM. Each question runs where the data lives and a small answer comes back. Nothing is copied out.
Proves the cause
A live check that confirms it, not a confidence score
Rootly. “A hypothesis with evidence, not a verdict,” rated high, medium or low.
3AM. A live check confirms the cause. Only a confirmed cause can authorize a fix.
Fixes, then verifies
Rehearsed first, then checked after it runs
Rootly. Private Agent can run writes such as SQL without interactive approval.
3AM. Every fix is dry-run first, applied with approval, then checked against the live system.
Two people approve
Not one person, and never switched off by an admin
Rootly. Not found in public docs.
3AM. Two different people approve one plan, and the plan cannot change after they sign.
No key to the books
A hard line around ledgers, journals and balances
Rootly. Not found in public docs.
3AM. No key to the books at any setting. A person runs a signed package with their own key.
Tamper-evident audit
Hash-chained and signed, verifiable by your auditors
Rootly. Not found in public docs.
3AM. Every step is hash-chained and signed, and exports to your SIEM.
One incident, two paths.
Rootly
- Alert
- Hypothesis checks
- Rated high, medium or low
- You act
3AM
- Alert
- Cause ranked
- Proven live
- Fix rehearsed
- Two people sign
- Recovery verified
Their steps are drawn from Rootly’s own documentation. Where a path ends, the rest is left to your people.
Rootly, in detail.
| Row | Rootly | 3AM |
|---|---|---|
| Where it runs | Rootly's cloud on AWS, with all inference in the US. Private Agent is in early preview. | Wholly inside your network, air-gapped if you need. The only call out is a signed license check. |
| What happens to your data | Read-only queries; some sources are ingested. Prompts and completions are logged for evaluation, with no opt-out. | Each question runs where the data lives and a small answer comes back. Nothing is copied out. |
| How it reaches a cause | Parallel hypothesis checks, rated high, medium or low. | A live check on your systems that can only pass if the cause is real. |
| What it can change | Private Agent writes, such as SQL, can run without interactive approval. | Dry-runs the fix, applies it with approval, then proves the system recovered. |
| Who signs a change | No multi-person approval found. | Two different people, on one plan that cannot change after they sign. |
Where it runs
Rootly. Rootly's cloud on AWS, with all inference in the US. Private Agent is in early preview.3AM. Wholly inside your network, air-gapped if you need. The only call out is a signed license check.What happens to your data
Rootly. Read-only queries; some sources are ingested. Prompts and completions are logged for evaluation, with no opt-out.3AM. Each question runs where the data lives and a small answer comes back. Nothing is copied out.How it reaches a cause
Rootly. Parallel hypothesis checks, rated high, medium or low.3AM. A live check on your systems that can only pass if the cause is real.What it can change
Rootly. Private Agent writes, such as SQL, can run without interactive approval.3AM. Dry-runs the fix, applies it with approval, then proves the system recovered.Who signs a change
Rootly. No multi-person approval found.3AM. Two different people, on one plan that cannot change after they sign.
The verdict.
Choose Rootly
If speed to start matters most and a hypothesis is enough, Rootly is a good fit.
Choose 3AM
If you need a verdict before anything runs, inference inside your own network, and two people on every write, choose 3AM.
- You need a verdict, not a hypothesis
- No write may run without approval, let alone two
- Inference must stay in your own country and network
Sources, read November 11, 2026
- Rootly blog, September 15, 2026
- Rootly docs, AI SRE overview
- Rootly docs, Data privacy for Rootly AI
- Rootly docs, Investigation rules
- Rootly docs, Private Agent
Compared on November 11, 2026 from each vendor's public website and documentation, linked on every page. Products change; if something here is out of date, write to [email protected] and we will correct it. All product names and trademarks belong to their owners and are used only to identify them. No affiliation or endorsement is implied.
Put us side by side on your own incidents.
- Stays in your network
- Humans hold the keys
- Tamper-evident
- Shadow first
